4 Things You Didn’t Know About Dune


Sneak preview of forthcoming graphic novel.

Sneak preview of forthcoming graphic novel.

Written almost 50 years ago, Dune is the world’s best-selling science fiction novel. As recently as 2012, the readers of Wired magazine voted it the top science fiction novel of all time.

Dune won the Hugo and Nebula awards, and it is consistently in the top three of nearly all science fiction lists (usually along with Ender’s Game and Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy). It’s a sprawling epic of Machiavellian politics, personal betrayals, secrets within secrets, giant monsters, and delightfully flawed characters. It’s often called the “Lord of the Rings of science fiction” and has inspired countless other science fiction novels.

The comparison to high fantasy is particularly apt given the small part technology plays. There are no robots and no computers. Spaceships are treated as transport vessels, not objects of wonder. There are castles, emperors, witches, dukes, dragons (sandworms), and a substance that bestows astounding powers when you eat it (spice).

This is all well-known, but there are a few things you may not know about Dune.


1. It was inspired by a trip to Oregon

Perhaps the most surprising fact about Dune is that Frank Herbert was inspired to create his all-desert, water-starved planet during a trip to the soggy Oregon coast. He watched people planting grass to keep the shifting dunes from swallowing up vacationers’ houses.


2. It was published by an outfit known for its car repair manuals.

Despite all this, Herbert couldn’t sell his book.

Publishers said it was too long. People who read science fiction, they said, don’t like long books (Apparently, neither do fantasy readers, since this was same reason given to J. K. Rowling when she was rejected multiple times for the first Harry Potter book).

After twenty rejections, an editor at Chilton (a publisher known for its car repair manuals) gave Dune a chance. It sold slowly at first, but eventually well enough that Herbert was able to become a full-time writer.


3. It has no authoritative visual

If Dune is so popular, why are there no conventions? Why don’t you see people dressing up as the hero Paul Atreides at various Comic-Cons? Where are the stillsuit costumes?

One possible reason is that there is no authoritative visual. If you wear something from the book, you have to tell someone it’s from Dune or they’d never know. Quick, what does a stillsuit look like? Or an ornithopter?

The Dune movie by David Lynch was, well, awful. Various TV shows have tried to capture the essence of Dune, with limited success. One movie had the potential to become this vision, to declare This Is How Dune Looks, but sadly, it was never made. This film was documented in Jorowsky’s Dune, a fascinating film in its own right. The specter of what might have been—the marvelous, surreal spectacle of a true Dune movie (e.g., designs by H.R. Giger, the man who created Alien, and starring Salvador Dali as the Emperor) is almost overwhelming to consider.


4. It has seventeen sequels and prequels

The success of Dune allowed Herbert to create a number of sequels, each slightly more disappointing than the previous. To enjoy these books after reading the original, lower your expectations. See the other novels as children playing around the feet of a wise old grandpa, and you’ll have a good enough time of it.

The Dune books by Frank’s son, Brian Herbert, and Kevin J. Anderson are more typical page-turners than heavy opuses like the original, but they’re still a lot of fun. There are worse ways to spend an afternoon.




5 thoughts on “4 Things You Didn’t Know About Dune

  1. I am always happy to read well-written blogs about spec fiction. I have been a lifelong fan of Dune by Herbert. I regret to have to point out that Analog magazine was edited by John W Campbell, a writer, iconic editor, for whom a sic-fi preeminent award is named. Although Herbert’s Dune does contain many elements of the hero’s journey archetypes, it has no editorial connection with the writer and academic Joseph Campbell who was a student of psychology, religion, comp lit, and taught at Sarah Lawrence College for many years. Joseph Campbell did befriend George Lucas late in life, but never wrote or edited any fiction to my knowledge, whereas John W. Campbell devoted his life to those pursuits.

    J Moss

  2. It is so naive for people to think Jodowski’s Dune would have been anything other then a splendid mess that stoners go hopped up to midnight movies to laugh and gawk about.

    The guy was the biggest ego trip(on a mental high that LSD couldn’t match) and the doc shows this over and over.

    The whole pompous thing with Dali was so cringe worthy and the bottom line was that this movie was never going to be made. If it ever had a chance the director shot it down in flames so tremendous that people jumping out of a burning Hindenberg would have pointed at this Hot Mess (while falling to their death) and be heard saying/ “Now that’s a fiery mess”

    Lynch’s Dune would have always been superior to this wackos version. In fact his claim to fame is a Invisible toilet with him playing a messiah taking a golden crap(Which he has multiple messiah complex issues in real life)

    Please quit pushing this false notion that the guy was anything but a Lunatic(which the doc also clearly shows)

  3. John Campbell was the editor of Analog Magazine who assisted Herbert in writing Dune and Dune Messiah.
    Joseph Campbell was the author of The Hero with a Thousand Faces, which expounded upon mythos of The Hero’s Journey.
    John Campbell is not Joseph Campbell.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.